HOME        ABOUT OUR OFFERING       ABOUT US AND OUR TEAM       PRESS       RESULTS       BLOG 🆕       FREE INITIAL CONSULTATION     

Blog 
Article

We have compiled an unparalleled repository of insights about ensuring interview success at McKinsey & Company, Boston Consulting Group (BCG), and Bain & Company. 

We regularly synthesize these insights into relevant blog articles around consulting interview preparation (with a focus on McKinsey, BCG, and Bain).
All Your Information is Protected When You Sign Up
Category: Case Interview Mastery for McKinsey, BCG, Bain
Case Interview Mastery: 
How to approach "Profitability Cases" in a superior way during MBB interviews
Written by Dr. Sidi S. Koné on Jun. 17th 2022
Given the many inaccuracies that have been spread by “case preparation books” over the last decade, we feel the need to explain a couple of crucial points regarding case structuring
Almost all candidates who interview with McKinsey, Bain, or BCG are struggling with the initial structuring of diagnostic situations, e.g., so-called "profitability cases". 
For example, they are insecure about whether in their initial structure they should already include Economy & Market trends (like suggested by many resources like, e.g., Case In Point). Or only stick to the internal perspective, and focus on competitive comparison later on when going into detail in the different branches of the problem.
"Structuring a case does NOT mean to just give the interviewer a list of all the "buckets" you're going to look at!"
This insecruity stems from a lack of precision and focus in almost all case preparation books on the market. 

Here is an ABSOLUTELY CENTRAL notion you must understand: 

Structuring a case does NOT mean to give just the interviewer a list of all the "buckets" you're going to look at! This would not be a proper structure - but just a bucket list... and a pretty random one most of the time!

Structuring a case means to explain to the interviewer the LOGIC according to which you will answer the question at hand. "Areas to look at" are just a byproduct of this logic.

Therefore it is not very helpful to start with defining qualitative "buckets" to look at (e.g., "I'm going to start with looking at the market, then I want to understand the customers etc."). This is, at the end of the day, quite random, with no clear logic from which your areas are derived (other than "experience" or "gut feeling", both of which are not what MBB interviewers are supposed to assess!). 

If you think about it, this approach is the opposite of how you should work as a strategy consultant! Defining buckets and then hoping to find something interesting in there is pure explorative working - another word for this is "guessing".

One fundamental thing that needs to be learned in order to rigorously disaggregate the value drivers of a business and, hence, business-related questions, is how to set up rigorous driver trees. The driver tree allows you to identify the numerical drivers and sub-drivers of your focus metric (e.g., profits). The qualitative elements (such as consumer demand, market structure, company operations, etc.) then have to be mapped to the sub-branches of this tree!

Hence, your analysis has two steps. Imagine you want to run a diagnostic on why profits have fallen:
  • First you need to identify the numerical driver of the problem (e.g., customer base is shrinking). This gives you an understanding of the WHAT has (mathematically) caused the problem (e.g., customer base has shrinked, which you would discover by drilling three or 4 levels down in your profit tree).
  • ​The second step is the understanding of the WHY (why has this cause emerged?). To do this, you have to examine the qualitative elements that link to the "number of customers"-sub-branch in your driver tree (e.g., competitive situation, market entries, new substitutes, relative price point, customer preferences, product/service properties vs. competition, etc.)
You can think of these qualitative elements as the typical business situation framework elements (see V. Cheng et al.) - but here, they are not hanging in the air anymore, but they are embedded in a rigorous thinking frame which emerges from the disaggregation of value drivers, and then linking them to qualitative reasons.
"Never start your analysis with asking qualitative questions"
Another aspect that is very important (and usually violated in Case Coaching books) is the principle of first isolating the numerical problem driver, before asking qualitative question. Never start your analysis with asking qualitative questions ("First I would like to get a general understanding of the market development" and such phrases)! This is practically the very definition of "boiling the ocean", i.e., working in an extremely inefficient way. 

Instead, you should first seek to narrow down the area which you even need to qualitatively understand! And this can be done very quickly by doing a numerical analysis as described above. Once you know where the problem comes from (the numerical problem driver), THEN you can start to understand the qualitative reasons that underlie the negative development of this driver. 

This analysis will be far more focused and concrete than if you would have tried to discuss qualitative reasons at the start.
Please also watch the below video which elaborates on this very topic:

How we can help you break you into McKinsey, BCG, or Bain

If you, as an applicant at one of the big strategy consulting firms, would like to learn how to ensure success in your interviews with McKinsey, BCG, or Bain, then feel free to apply for a free initial consultation with us. In this free session we will find out whether we can help you, and if so, how we can help you to reach your goal of joining a firm like McKinsey, BCG, or Bain & Company. 

Within the last years, we have helped more than 350 people to receive job offers from the three MBB companies! On average, every single week, two of our clients are signing an employment contract with either McKinsey, BCG, or Bain.

About the author: 
Dr. Sidi S. Koné

Former Senior Engagement Manager and Interviewer at McKinsey & Company | Former Senior Consultant at BCG

About The MBB Offer Machine™

We help aspiring graduates, young professionals, and seasoned topic experts to ensure success in their job interviews with the world's most reputable Strategy Consulting Firms.

We place a special emphasis on "MBB":
  • McKinsey & Company
  • ​Boston Consulting Group (BCG)
  • ​Bain & Company

About the author: 
Dr. Sidi S. Koné

Former Senior Engagement Manager and Interviewer at McKinsey & Company | Former Senior Consultant at BCG

About the author: 
Dr. Sidi S. Koné

Former Senior Engagement Manager and Interviewer at McKinsey & Company | Former Senior Consultant at BCG
Share Us
Imprint      |     Privacy     |     Disclaimer
This site is not a part of the Facebook website or Facebook Inc. 
Additionally, this site is NOT endorsed by Facebook in any way. FACEBOOK is a trademark of FACEBOOK, Inc.

McKinsey & Company, Boston Consulting Group (BCG), and Bain & Company, as well as any derivations from said names (including the names of other firms used on this site) are registered trademarks of their respective owners.